Atlas Support
ResearchEconomicsWritten and edited by:

Instruction Theory: Complete and Incomplete Instructions and the Boundary Between Humans and AI

Atlas Support’s Economic Research team introduces a theory draft on what people should specify before delegating work to AI and which decisions they should retain.

When incomplete instructions can still be sufficient

An instruction is complete when the interpretations consistent with it and the shared context lead to the same set of actions in each situation. Even when interpretations differ, an action that is optimal for all of them can allow the AI to proceed without clarification.

The cost of specifying and clarifying

The model compares doing the work directly, writing a complete instruction, and delegating with clarification at selected decision points. It accounts for the time spent writing instructions and answering questions, including the value of reusing an answer in later cases.